Cancer can still occur after successful eradication of dysplasia with radiofrequency ablation.
Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for patients with Barrett esophagus with high-grade dysplasia (HGD) has been clearly established as an acceptable and preferred treatment option for the majority of these patients. In the initial multicenter trial, RFA completely eradicated dysplasia in 91% of patients with HGD (JW Gastroenterol May 27 2009) and in 95% who were followed up for 2 years. Repeat RFA was performed in 55% of patients after the 1-year primary end point — mostly based on the discretion of the endoscopist rather than biopsy indication (JW Gastroenterol Nov 4 2011). No cancers were reported. The inference by some clinicians is that patients who have had successful ablative therapy can be considered cured and can be discontinued from surveillance. However, a new case report provides contrary evidence.
Three patients underwent successful RFA treatment of Barrett esophagus with HGD at tertiary academic centers; procedures were performed by nationally recognized experts in RFA. Two patients underwent endoscopic mucosal resection before RFA. The first patient had five post-RFA surveillance endoscopies during 2 years before subsquamous HGD was detected. The second patient had normal neosquamous epithelium at 3 months but subsquamous esophageal adenocarcinoma detected at 6 months. The third patient underwent two endoscopies at 3-month intervals, and at 9 months, a nodular area was noted and a subsquamous esophageal adenocarcinoma was detected.
Comment: This report emphasizes the ongoing risk for cancer following successful RFA treatment in patients with Barrett esophagus and HGD. These cases clearly demonstrate the need for meticulous surveillance. However, until the optimal surveillance schedule after ablative therapy is defined in national guidelines, experts currently recommend surveillance intervals of 3 months in year 1, 6 months in year 2, and 1 year thereafter. Quadrant biopsies should be taken every 1 cm in addition to separate biopsies of any visible lesions. Although RFA poses less risk than surgery, it is far from a cure.
Source: Journal Watch Gastroenterology