Did Jack Really Need to Sacrifice Himself for Rose?


James Cameron commissioned a study to prove that his characters’ tragic ending was inevitable


Leonardo DiCaprio as Jack and Kate Winslet as Rose after the Titanic has sunk

For 25 years, skeptics have been insisting that Jack and Rose could have both survived on their makeshift raft.

Spoiler alert: Titanicdoesn’t have a happy ending.

James Cameron’s 1997 film follows Jack and Rose, portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet, respectively. They’re both passengers aboard the Titanic, but they’re from vastly different worlds, separated by class. Of course, they fall in love anyway. And when the Titanic hits an iceberg and sinks to the bottom of the ocean, Jack performs one final act of love: He helps Rose onto a floating wooden board—and remains in the freezing water beside her. Rose makes it. Jack doesn’t.

Over the past 25 years, the gesture has racked up a whole lot of skepticism. Did Jack really need to sacrifice his own life for Rose to survive? Couldn’t he have shared that piece of wood with her?

But Cameron, who has always maintained that the script calls for Jack to die, is determined to put an end to these questions. “We have done a scientific study to put this whole thing to rest and drive a stake through its heart once and for all,” he tells the Toronto Sun’s Mark Daniell.

The study consisted of “a thorough forensic analysis with a hypothermia expert who reproduced the raft from the movie” as well as “two stunt people who were the same body mass of Kate and Leo,” Cameron continues. “We put sensors all over them and inside them and we put them in ice water and we tested to see whether they could have survived through a variety of methods. And the answer was, there was no way they both could have survived. Only one could survive.”

It’s not the first time Titanic’s tragic endinghas been put to the test. Jack and Rose’s raft was the subject of a 2012 episode of “MythBusters,” which came to the conclusion that Jack and Rose could have shared the board and made it out alive—if they secured Rose’s life jacket underneath.

“I think you guys are missing the point here,” Cameron said in the episode. “The script said Jack dies. He has to die. So maybe we screwed up and the board should have been a little tiny bit smaller, but the dude’s going down.”

Besides, the hosts of “MythBusters” didn’t account for how the water’s temperature would have affected their proposed plan of action, Cameron told the Daily Beast’s Marlow Stern in 2017. “You’re underwater tying this thing on in 28-degree water, and that’s going to take you five to ten minutes, so by the time you come back up you’re already dead,” he said. 

The findings of Cameron’s study will be explained in a National Geographic special in February 2023. Around the same time, a remastered version of Titanic will hit theaters in honor of the film’s 25th anniversary. 

With his special, Cameron hopes the skeptics will finally leave him alone. “Maybe … maybe … after 25 years, I won’t have to deal with this anymore,” he tells the Toronto Sun.

Sarah Purkey, an oceanographer at the University of California at San Diego, tells the Washington Post’s Praveena Somasundaram that any answers will come down to buoyancy and gravity: The buoyancy of the wooden board must be greater than or equal to the gravity from Jack and Rose. “That’s how boats float, and that’s how a piece of driftwood floats,” she says. “And it’s going to sink if gravity is more than its buoyancy.”

But either way, she adds, if the study gets people thinking about physics, “then it’s great.”

Things You Didnt Know About Titanic


1912 marks one of the biggest tragedies ever – a tragedy we know as the Titanic! It is heartbreaking to even recall all that we’ve read about it or seen in James Cameron’s brilliant adaptation of the same. But, here are 21 facts about the Titanic you probably never knew before.

1. Kate Winslet refused to wear a wetsuit while filming the iconic water scene from the film. But staying in water for such prolonged periods of time made her fall sick with pneumonia.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

2. According to a recent theory, the sinking of the Titanic could have taken place because of a full moon that occurred months before the disaster happened. It is said that it created strong tides and changed the position of some icebergs that may have come in the way of the ship. It is also believed that it was no common full moon. Earth hadn’t seen such a full moon since 796 A.D. and wouldn’t ever, until 2257.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

3. There was a ship called Californian in the vicinity of Titanic that could have saved its passengers. But, Californian’s wireless operator went off to sleep early that night, while the Titanic sent out distress signals, one after the other, hoping they would get a response. It is said that even when the crew of Californian tried to wake the wireless operator up, he did not issue any orders to help Titanic. But thankfully, another ship called Carpathia came to the rescue and saved as many people as it could.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

4. Leonardo DiCaprio used to carry his pet lizard to the sets of the film. It once got ran over by a truck but Leonardo gave it a new life by taking good care of it.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

5. Milton Hershey, the founder of Hersheys chocolates was supposed to be on board in Titanic. But fortunately, he cancelled his reservation at the end moment!

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

6. A film based on the sinking of Titanic called ‘Saved From The Titanic’ was released just 29 days after the disaster. It featured Dorothy Gibson, one of the survivors. She wore the same dress on the sets of the film that she did on that unfateful day the Titanic sank. Reliving those moments affected Dorothy’s health so adversely, she had a mental breakdown.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

7. The movie had a scene showing the musicians on the ship still playing as it sank and people drowned. That actually happened when the real Titanic sank. Those musicians played for hours and none of them survived.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

8. When Titanic sank, the first draft of the London Daily mail wrongly reported the incident claiming that no lives were lost! It was later updated.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

9. Robert De Niro was approached for the role of Captain Smith but he declined the offer because he was suffering from a gastrointestinal infection.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

10. The chief baker of the Titanic had consumed a lot of alcohol the same night the ship sank. As a result, his body was warm enough to keep him alive in the cold for 2 hours till he was rescued.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

11. Matthew McConaughey was the production studio’s first choice to play the lead but director James Cameron insisted that they sign Leonardo DiCaprio instead. The rest, as they say, is history!

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

12. Of the 1514 people who died, only 336 bodies were found.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

13. Gloria Stuart, the 87 year old woman who played the old Rose, was the only person in the movie, who was alive in 1912, when Titanic actually sank. She also became the oldest person ever to be nominated for an Oscar with this film.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

14. While the film was being shot, someone on the sets spiked the cast and crews food with PCP (also called angel dust). It was reported that most of them had hallucinations that day and about 80 people were hospitalized.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

15. James Cameron didn’t even know a passenger called J.Dawsom had actually died in the Titanic disaster in 1912 when he wrote Leonardo Di Caprio’s character.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

16. Titanic, the ship, was actually constructed for $7.5 million, which would approximately be equivalent to $150 million in 1997. The film, Titanic, shot in 1997, cost more than $200 million!

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

17. The scene where the Grand Staircase room gets flooded had to be shot in a single go because the sets would be destroyed.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

18. The sketches that Jack makes in the film were actually made by James Cameron himself! The hands shown sketching in the movie were not Leo’s but James Cameron’s. What a man!

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

19. Director James Cameron and the Studios considered a lot of actresses like Nicole Kidman, Cameron Diaz, Sharon Stone to play Rose, before they zeroed in on Kate Winslet.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

20. The scene where Leonardo sketches a nude Kate Winslet was one of the most beautiful scenes in the film and the director and the actors wanted it to be perfect. Just to make the scene a little less awkward, Kate Winslet flashed Leonardo DiCaprio the first time they met on the sets.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

21. The film was originally going to be called ‘Planet Ice’.

Things You Didn’t Know About Titanic

 

 

10 Facts You May Not Know About ‘Titanic’ .


With the freak snowfall we had yesterday in my area, it was a shocking and ironic reminder that today is the 103rd anniversary of the the sinking of the S.S. Titanic. Trying to keep myself warm today, I thought that I would set my sights on a lighter topic and “celebrate” with some fun facts that you may not have known from the making of the blockbuster hit Titanic.

Gloria Stuart was the only member of the crew who was alive when the Titanic sank

At 87-years-old she is also the oldest person to have been nominated for an Oscar. She lost to Kim Basinger, who won for her work in L.A. Confidential.

Reba McEntire was offered the role of Molly Brown but turned it down due to scheduling conflicts

She definitely would have brought a little spice to the role!

Kate Winslet was the only crew member who refused to wear a wet suit in this scene

Thanks to this, she caught pneumonia…

James Cameron actually drew all of Jack’s sketches in the film

That is actually James’ hand, not Leonardo’s.

After finding out that she had to be naked in front of Leonardo, Kate flashed him when they first met

Well, that is certainly one way to break the ice.

After writing the script, James found out there was a real “J. Dawson” who died on board the S.S. Titanic

I guess he “let go.”

When Jack says “Lie on the bed, uh, I mean couch” that was actually a mistake

It was actually just meant to be “Lie on the couch” but Leo messed up. James liked it so much that he kept it in the film.

James actually didn’t want any songs in the film

It probably would have saved a lot of karaoke attendees some headaches and would have been one less song stuck in our heads… but would our hearts have gone on?

Now try to get it out… Oops.

The studio wanted Matthew McConaughey to play Jack and Gwyneth Paltrow was up for the role of Rose

I think we can all agree that it would have been a VERY different movie if those casting choices had gone through.

It’s the first movie that James wrote and directed that didn’t include or mention nuclear weapons

Though, let’s face it, there was mass destruction…

I hope I didn’t spoil it for you, but yes, the boat does sink at the end.

This movie is an enjoyable one, whether you watch for the artistry, for the romance, or you just want to see a boat sink and make yourself never want to take a cruise… ever, it’s never a boring ride when you sit down to watch TItanic.