Critically ill patients treated with hydroxyethyl starch face increased risks for kidney damage and mortality, according to a JAMA meta-analysis. The dangers, once considered of borderline significance, became apparent when the data of a disgraced researcher were removed from the analysis.
The researchers examined mortality and renal-outcome data from some 40 trials comparing hydroxyethyl starch with other fluids given to patients for volume resuscitation. Seven of those trials — by a researcher whose later work was retracted after a government investigation — were removed. After that removal, results changed from showing no mortality advantage with starch to a significant mortality risk. Kidney damage, as reflected by the need for renal-replacement therapy, also increased.
Editorialists point out the serious consequences to patients of scientific misconduct. They conclude: “The harms of hydroxyethyl starch most likely outweigh the benefits.”
Source: JAMA